Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label AfD

Germany: From Heine's Warnings to Wortmann's Premature Celebration

Does the German poet Heinrich Heine have anything relevant today' Germany? Yes,  Heinrich Heine  is astoundingly relevant to today's Germany , so much so that his 19th-century writings read like a contemporary commentary on the nation's modern cultural, political, and social struggles.  [1, 2]  Though he spent the last 25 years of his life exiled in Paris, his complex relationship with his homeland—a mix of deep longing, bitter irony, and fierce critique—laid the groundwork for how modern Germany views itself.  [3, 4, 5]  1. A Prophet of the 20th Century (and Beyond) Heine is famously studied in Germany today for his uncanny, haunting ability to look into the future. In his 1821 play  Almansor , he wrote a line that is now engraved at the Bebelplatz Memorial in Berlin, where the Nazis burned books in 1933:  [6]  "Where they burn books, they will ultimately burn people also."  [4]  This quote cements Heine as Germany’s absolute mora...

Distorting, Fabricating, Denying History

Claims on Facebook Claim: China’s most infamous traitor, General Wu Sangui; the guy who opened the gates of the Great Wall and allowed the Manchu hordes to invade China.  Why would someone compare that with Merkel in Germany accepting a million or so refugees? While rhetorically powerful for anti-immigration commentators, the comparison collapses under historical scrutiny: Intent and Motivation:  General Wu Sangui acted out of  military desperation and personal vengeance  to defeat domestic rebels, knowing he was allying with an invading military force. Merkel acted out of  humanitarian duty  to address a massive humanitarian crisis during the Syrian civil war. Nature of the Influx:  Wu Sangui let in a  highly organized, hostile military army  intent on conquest and regime change. Merkel accepted  disarmed, displaced civilian refugees  seeking asylum under international law. The Outcome:  Wu’s actions immediately led to the...