With our eye on the native, the American Revolution of 1776 no longer seems like the prelude to the “first new nation,” as [Seymour Martin] Lipset called it. Rather, the revolution merely ushered a different group of white settlers into the seats of government. This was not a revolution*, because the ideology of the state was maintained; it was a rebellion, a change of leadership. During its first 150 years, America did not celebrate the revolution; it celebrated the “War of Independence.” This was apt terminology, for the independence of the United States was akin to the independence of Liberia in 1847 under black-settler rule, South Africa in 1910 under white-settler rule, and Israel in 1948 under Zionist-settler rule. Had Ian Smith and his followers succeeded in 1974, an independent white settler–ruled Rhodesia would have joined these ranks. America mistakes itself for a new kind of nation, whereas in fact it is the continuation of the settler-colonial nation that the Crown and other Europeans created.
—Mahmood Mamdani, Neither Settler nor Native, ebook version, 2020, pp. 112-13
*Scholars like Mamdani emphasise that the 1776 transition was primarily a shift in leadership from an overseas elite (the British Crown) to a local elite (the American colonists). Unlike the French or Haitian Revolutions, which fundamentally dismantled the existing social hierarchies, property relations, and legal structures, the American war left the internal legal and socio-economic foundations intact. Wealthy property owners, merchants, and slaveholders retained their status and power.
Comments