Skip to main content

Posts

The Break-Up of the UK (?)

The talk these days in Britain is again about the possible break up of the UK. Writing in 1977, during a decade marked by severe economic stagnation, IMF bailouts, and the initial emergence of the SNP, Tom Nairn famously predicted the "slow foundering" of the United Kingdom.  His core argument was that the UK is not a modern democratic nation-state, but an archaic, imperial relic whose structural flaws make its collapse inevitable.  Because Britain was the world's first industrial power, its rising capitalist bourgeoisie made a pact with the old agrarian aristocracy rather than overthrowing them. It never had a true democratic revolution The UK retained a fundamentally "pre-modern," centralized constitutional framework based on the absolute sovereignty of the  "Queen in Parliament"  rather than the sovereignty of the people. Nairn mockingly dubbed this encrusted, uncodified political system  "Ukania". According to Nairn, this archaic state st...

Distorting, Fabricating, Denying History

Claims on Facebook Claim: China’s most infamous traitor, General Wu Sangui; the guy who opened the gates of the Great Wall and allowed the Manchu hordes to invade China.  Why would someone compare that with Merkel in Germany accepting a million or so refugees? While rhetorically powerful for anti-immigration commentators, the comparison collapses under historical scrutiny: Intent and Motivation:  General Wu Sangui acted out of  military desperation and personal vengeance  to defeat domestic rebels, knowing he was allying with an invading military force. Merkel acted out of  humanitarian duty  to address a massive humanitarian crisis during the Syrian civil war. Nature of the Influx:  Wu Sangui let in a  highly organized, hostile military army  intent on conquest and regime change. Merkel accepted  disarmed, displaced civilian refugees  seeking asylum under international law. The Outcome:  Wu’s actions immediately led to the...